The New York Yankees’ bullpen has been a hot mess this season and Friday night’s game against the Toronto Blue Jays only added to the problem. Closer Devin Williams blew another save and the crowd at Yankee Stadium was chanting “We want Weaver”. The 30-year-old right-hander didn’t get an out in the 9th inning, gave up a single, hit a batter and a 2-run double to Alejandro Kirk that turned a 2-1 lead into a 4-2 loss.
Williams’ struggles have reached a boiling point and his response to the growing fan unrest was as cold as the game itself.
“Everybody Has Their Opinion”: Williams on the Chants
When asked about the crowd’s chants for Luke Weaver, Williams said: “Everybody has their opinion”
When pressed further on how it made him feel, he said: “I don’t have an opinion on that.”
Clearly Williams is feeling the weight of his recent performances—or lack thereof. His ERA is 11.25 over 10 appearances this season and opponents are batting .286 against his once unstoppable “Airbender” changeup. The pitch that used to be almost unhittable now has a 22.4% whiff rate and a .486 expected slugging percentage—big drops from his 2024 season.
What’s Wrong With Devin Williams?
Williams didn’t sugarcoat it after the game. “Nothing is working right now,” he said.
The numbers back him up. Hitters are squaring him up more and his command is spotty at best. For a guy who lives on deception and movement, even small mistakes can be disastrous. And for Williams, those mistakes have come at the worst times.
Despite earlier votes of confidence from manager Aaron Boone and pitching coach Matt Blake, the pressure is mounting for the Yankees to reevaluate Williams as closer. When asked if a change was coming, Boone hedged: “We’ll see,” meaning all options are on the table.
Luke Weaver: The Fans’ Choice
While Williams stumbles, Luke Weaver has been the most reliable arm in the Yankees’ bullpen. The 31-year-old righty has thrown 13 scoreless innings to start the season, striking out 13 and allowing just 2 hits. The fans have noticed and are growing louder in their demands to see him as closer.
Weaver’s performance is the opposite of Williams’. Where Williams can’t find answers, Weaver is providing stability and big time pitching when the team needs it.
The Decision Ahead
The Yankees are at a fork in the road. Do they stick with Williams and hope he gets it back or go with Weaver as closer? The choice will have big implications for the team’s future. One thing is for sure, the Yankees need to win these close games if they want to be in the AL East hunt.
For now, the tension between the struggling incumbent and the rising alternative is the juiciest subplot of the season. Fans may be chanting for Weaver, but ultimately it’s up to the coaching staff to make the tough call.